Custodial Death Case Resurfaces
Subject: Polity and Governance
Topic: Law Enforcement Accountability

The article discusses a significant custodial death case from March 1993, which bears similarities to a recent case involving the illegal detention and murder of Ajith Kumar in Sivaganga, Tamil Nadu.

Summary:

  • On March 20, 1993, Kadirvel Padayachi reported a theft of 43 sovereigns of jewelry to the Kammapuram police station, implicating members of the Kuravar community in the alleged crime.

  • Police officials, including Sub Inspector Anthonisami, detained Rajakannu, an agricultural laborer from the Kuravar community, along with his family members, without sufficient evidence, leading to their brutal treatment at the station.

  • Rajakannu’s wife, Parvathy, witnessed the police's inhumane treatment when she visited the station with food for her husband the day after his arrest. She saw him stripped, tied, and severely beaten, suffering from multiple injuries.

  • After Rajakannu's condition worsened, a homeopathy doctor was called in, but police continued the torture subsequently. Ultimately, Parvathy learned from locals that the police fabricated a story of Rajakannu escaping custody.

  • For a month, the whereabouts of Rajakannu remained unknown. Parvathy sought legal assistance from K. Chandru, who later became a judge, and filed a habeas corpus petition to locate him.

  • An investigation revealed that Rajakannu had been murdered, with evidence showing he had been beaten to death at the police station. The autopsy indicated multiple injuries that corroborated police brutality, including fractures likely caused by severe physical violence.

  • The High Court eventually identified the case's circumstances and confirmed the offences against specific police personnel, resulting in their conviction for Rajakannu's murder.

  • This case was referenced in the acclaimed Tamil film "Jai Bhim," which highlighted the injustices faced by marginalized communities in India. Despite its hopeful portrayal, the reality was stark as Rajakannu's body was never returned to his family.

  • The police convictions for custodial deaths remain alarmingly low in Tamil Nadu and across India, with statistics indicating a considerable lack of accountability.

  • The High Court's commentary underscored the systemic failure of law enforcement and judicial processes that contribute to a culture of impunity and neglect concerning custodial violence.

Key Points:

  • The incident occurred following a jewelry theft complaint on March 20, 1993.
  • Rajakannu and his family were illegally detained and tortured at Kammapuram police station.
  • Parvathy sought help from local activists and legal counsel after her husband's disappearance.
  • An inquiry led to the discovery of Rajakannu's body with multiple injuries, confirming police culpability.
  • Evidence showed that the police attempted to cover up the murder by fabricating a story of escape.
  • The case resulted in convictions against the involved police officers, highlighting issues of accountability in custodial deaths.
  • The film “Jai Bhim” (2021) brought broader awareness to the injustices surrounding the case.
  • Nonsensical or fabricated explanations by police lead to a persistent issue with custodial deaths, representing systemic failures in India's criminal justice system.
Key Terms, Keywords and Fact Used in the Article:
  • Kammapuram police station - Location of custodial death
  • Sivaganga district - Recent crime location
  • Kuravar community - Involved community
  • Madras High Court - Court handling case
  • Jai Bhim - Film based on case
  • IPS officer B. Perumalsamy - Investigator in case
  • Chief Minister - Political authority contacted
  • habeas corpus petition - Legal action taken
  • Custodial Death Case Resurfaces
    Custodial Death Case Resurfaces
    Subject: Polity and Governance
    Topic: Law Enforcement Accountability

    The article discusses a significant custodial death case from March 1993, which bears similarities to a recent case involving the illegal detention and murder of Ajith Kumar in Sivaganga, Tamil Nadu.

    Summary:

    • On March 20, 1993, Kadirvel Padayachi reported a theft of 43 sovereigns of jewelry to the Kammapuram police station, implicating members of the Kuravar community in the alleged crime.

    • Police officials, including Sub Inspector Anthonisami, detained Rajakannu, an agricultural laborer from the Kuravar community, along with his family members, without sufficient evidence, leading to their brutal treatment at the station.

    • Rajakannu’s wife, Parvathy, witnessed the police's inhumane treatment when she visited the station with food for her husband the day after his arrest. She saw him stripped, tied, and severely beaten, suffering from multiple injuries.

    • After Rajakannu's condition worsened, a homeopathy doctor was called in, but police continued the torture subsequently. Ultimately, Parvathy learned from locals that the police fabricated a story of Rajakannu escaping custody.

    • For a month, the whereabouts of Rajakannu remained unknown. Parvathy sought legal assistance from K. Chandru, who later became a judge, and filed a habeas corpus petition to locate him.

    • An investigation revealed that Rajakannu had been murdered, with evidence showing he had been beaten to death at the police station. The autopsy indicated multiple injuries that corroborated police brutality, including fractures likely caused by severe physical violence.

    • The High Court eventually identified the case's circumstances and confirmed the offences against specific police personnel, resulting in their conviction for Rajakannu's murder.

    • This case was referenced in the acclaimed Tamil film "Jai Bhim," which highlighted the injustices faced by marginalized communities in India. Despite its hopeful portrayal, the reality was stark as Rajakannu's body was never returned to his family.

    • The police convictions for custodial deaths remain alarmingly low in Tamil Nadu and across India, with statistics indicating a considerable lack of accountability.

    • The High Court's commentary underscored the systemic failure of law enforcement and judicial processes that contribute to a culture of impunity and neglect concerning custodial violence.

    Key Points:

    • The incident occurred following a jewelry theft complaint on March 20, 1993.
    • Rajakannu and his family were illegally detained and tortured at Kammapuram police station.
    • Parvathy sought help from local activists and legal counsel after her husband's disappearance.
    • An inquiry led to the discovery of Rajakannu's body with multiple injuries, confirming police culpability.
    • Evidence showed that the police attempted to cover up the murder by fabricating a story of escape.
    • The case resulted in convictions against the involved police officers, highlighting issues of accountability in custodial deaths.
    • The film “Jai Bhim” (2021) brought broader awareness to the injustices surrounding the case.
    • Nonsensical or fabricated explanations by police lead to a persistent issue with custodial deaths, representing systemic failures in India's criminal justice system.
    img

    Tragic Dowry Death in Uttar Pradesh

    Summary:

    The tragic case of Kanchan and Nikki Payla, two sisters from Roopwas village in Gautam Budh Nagar, Uttar Pradesh, highlights severe issues related to dowry and domestic violence in India. Both sisters were married in 2016 to brothers from the Bhati family in Sirsa, Haryana. They were allegedly subjected to abuse following their marriage, particularly after they started a makeup business that gained significant traction on social media with nearly 90,000 followers.

    Key Events:

    • Marriage and Background: In 2016, Kanchan (19) and Nikki (17) were married to Rohit and Vipin Bhati, respectively, with the Paylas providing substantial dowry, including an SUV, cash, and gold jewelry.
    • Abuse Allegations: The sisters reported ongoing harassment and pressure from their husbands and in-laws to abandon their business ventures, which they claimed contributed to the escalating domestic violence.
    • Death of Nikki Payla: On August 21, 2025, Nikki suffered severe burn injuries and died en route to the hospital. Her family suspects she was murdered due to dowry-related motives and business jealousy.
    • FIR Filed: Kanchan reported the incident to the police the next day, alleging that her in-laws were responsible for Nikki’s death, leading to the arrest of her husband and his relatives on charges of murder and attempt to commit serious offenses under the new Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
    • Evidence and Arrests: Following the complaints, the police made arrests, including that of Vipin, who reportedly attempted to shoot at the police. The family's accusations were substantiated by videos taken by Kanchan during the incident, which went viral on social media.

    Legal and Societal Context:

    • The case connects deeply with the broader issue of dowry deaths in India, where the National Crime Records Bureau reported 6,459 dowry deaths in 2022, with a significant portion occurring in Uttar Pradesh.
    • Current legal provisions under the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961 and Section 304(B) therein provide a framework for prosecution, but the enforcement remains challenging. The legislation stipulates that if a woman dies within seven years of marriage due to dowry-related circumstances, her in-laws can be held accountable.

    Comments from Officials:

    • The Chairperson of the National Commission for Women condemned the situation, indicating a cultural issue where daughters are viewed as property and emphasizing the need for societal change to eradicate such practices.

    Legal Proceedings and Evidence Controversies:

    • New evidence, including CCTV footage and conflicting testimonies, has led the police to consider changing the charges against the accused from murder to abetment of suicide, which could lead to lesser penalties.

    Call for Action:

    • The case is emblematic of the need for enhanced support systems for women facing domestic violence and better legal protections. Activists argue that community sentiments often lead families to send abused daughters back to their marital homes out of fear of societal backlash.

    This report shows the complexities of domestic violence, societal pressures related to dowry, and the persistent challenges faced by women in India in seeking justice.

    Key Points:

    • Sisters Kanchan and Nikki were married in 2016; both faced abuse post-marriage.
    • Nikki died from burn injuries on August 21, 2025; alleged murder linked to dowry demands.
    • FIR filed on August 22, 2025, leading to multiple arrests.
    • Legal provisions under Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961 exist but enforcement is weak.
    • National Commission for Women's condemnation highlights ongoing societal issues.
    • Evidence conflict may lead to reduced culpability for accused.
    • Women’s rights activists stress the need for systemic societal change to (prevent such incidents).

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Centenary of Self-Respect Movement Conference

    Summary of the News Article:

    Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K. Stalin is scheduled to address the Self-Respect Movement and its Legacies Conference 2025 at the University of Oxford on September 4, as part of a week-long visit to Germany and the U.K. starting August 30, 2025. This conference aims to commemorate the centenary of the Self-Respect Movement, co-hosted by St. Antony’s College and Balliol College at Oxford.

    Key Highlights:

    • Event and Significance:

      • The conference on September 4-5, 2025, seeks to globalize the Self-Respect Movement, which has significantly impacted Tamil Nadu’s socio-political framework by challenging caste and gender hierarchies.
      • CM Stalin will unveil a portrait of social reformer Periyar E.V. Ramasamy at Oxford, emphasizing that Periyar's ideals of self-respect, rationalism, and equality have universal relevance.
    • Economic Developments in Tamil Nadu:

      • CM Stalin stated that since the ‘Dravidian Model’ administration came into power, Tamil Nadu has attracted investments totaling ₹10 lakh crore.
      • He noted strong interest from international investors and industrialists in Tamil Nadu during his overseas trips.
    • Books and Interaction:

      • During the conference, CM Stalin will also launch two books that document the centenary journey of the Self-Respect Movement and discuss its relevance in the modern context.
      • On September 5, he is expected to engage with Indian students and graduates in London to foster connections with the diaspora.
    • Strategic Objectives:

      • The conference intends to engage scholars and practitioners to explore the ongoing significance of self-respect as a political and ethical principle.
      • The discussion will bridge the Dravidian experience with global movements such as civil rights, anti-apartheid struggles, and current mobilizations against systemic inequalities.

    This initiative reflects the commitment of the Tamil Nadu government to bring attention to social reforms initiated by Periyar and demonstrates the potential for local movements to engage in global discussions on equality and justice.

    Important Points:

    • CM M.K. Stalin will address a conference at Oxford on the Self-Respect Movement on September 4, 2025.
    • He will unveil Periyar E.V. Ramasamy's portrait as part of the commemoration.
    • The conference, co-hosted by St. Antony’s and Balliol Colleges, runs from September 4-5, 2025.
    • Tamil Nadu has attracted ₹10 lakh crore in investments under the current government.
    • Stalin will launch two significant books on the history and relevance of the Self-Respect Movement.
    • The conference aims to discuss the universal principles of self-respect and relate them to global movements against oppression.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Ministry Funds Infrastructure at CUTN

    The Ministry of Education has sanctioned a funding of ₹385.27 crore through the Higher Education Financing Agency (HEFA) for a comprehensive infrastructure expansion at the Central University of Tamil Nadu (CUTN) in Thiruvarur. This investment aims to enhance academic and residential facilities, thereby supporting the growth and development of the university in the context of national higher education.

    Key Points:

    • Funding Approval: The Ministry has approved ₹385.27 crore under the HEFA for infrastructure expansion at CUTN.

    • Project Goals: The funding is intended for the construction of new academic and residential facilities.

    • Specific Constructed Facilities:

      • New Academic Building: ₹96.40 crore allocated.
      • 300-bedded Girls Hostel: ₹46.63 crore.
      • 300-bedded Boys Hostel: ₹46.91 crore.
      • Scientific Instrumentation Centre: ₹19.95 crore.
      • Procurement of Scientific Instruments: ₹16.84 crore.
      • Expansion of Administrative Building: ₹46.16 crore.
      • Quarters for Faculty and Staff: ₹62.97 crore.
      • 400-bedded Research Scholar Hostel: ₹42.60 crore.
    • Focus on Advanced Research: Establishment of a Science Instrumentation Centre with advanced instruments for research purposes is a key component of the expansion.

    • Enhancement of Facilities: The investment will improve the university's learning environment, upgrade residential facilities for students and research scholars, and provide modern laboratories and instruments.

    • Support for National Education Development: This expansion is in line with the goals of enhancing higher education infrastructure in India.

    The funding from HEFA is expected to largely be supported through grants from the Ministry of Education, underscoring the government's commitment to improving educational infrastructure and supporting academic institutions in meeting the evolving needs of students and faculty. The projects reaffirm the government's objective of bolstering higher education and research capabilities in the country.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Pre-test for Population Census 2027

    The upcoming Population Census, set for 2027, is being prepared with a pre-test exercise scheduled for October and November 2023. This exercise is crucial for assessing the feasibility and effectiveness of the full census process, which will be carried out in two phases: Houselisting and Housing Schedule (HLO), and Population Enumeration. The enumeration phase is slated to occur between April 1, 2026, and February 28, 2027. Significant highlights of this census include:

    • First Digital Census: This will be India’s first census conducted digitally, utilizing a mobile application for data collection.
    • Caste Enumeration: It is also notable as the first census in independent India to include questions regarding caste.
    • Comprehensive Pre-test: The pre-test will evaluate various aspects including proposed questions, data collection methodologies, training protocols, logistics, printing processes, and data quality to identify potential field issues.

    Historical Context:

    • The last census was conducted in 2011, and an exercise planned for 2021 was postponed due to the COVID-19 pandemic; thus, the next census will actually take place in 2027.
    • The pre-test preceding the 2021 Census was held in 2019 and included around 2.6 million people from 76 districts across 36 States and Union Territories, employing approximately 6,000 enumerators and 1,100 supervisors.

    Current Developments:

    • The current pre-test will focus solely on the initial phase concerning household data, foregoing the second enumeration phase where caste will be recorded.
    • The Government of India, as of July 29, stated in the Lok Sabha that there will be no update to the National Population Register (NPR) during the upcoming census exercise.

    Background on NPR:

    • The NPR was established under the Citizenship Rules of 2003 and the Citizenship Act of 1955, with the first compilation occurring in 2010 during the 2011 Census.
    • The NPR database holds the details of approximately 1.19 billion residents and had been updated in 2015-16.
    • It is significant as it is considered a precursor to the National Register of Citizens (NRC).

    Additional Information:

    • The Registrar General of India (RGI), Mrityunjay Kumar Narayan, has directed State Directors of Census Operations (DCOs) regarding the pre-test and emphasized the importance of finalizing administrative boundaries by December 31 before the census.

    Key Takeaways:

    • Pre-test Dates: October and November 2023.
    • Census Dates: April 1, 2026, to February 28, 2027.
    • First Digital Census: Utilizes a mobile app for data collection.
    • Caste Enumeration: First in independent India.
    • No NPR Update: No decision to update the NPR during the census.
    • Historical Reference: Last census was in 2011; 2021 attempt was postponed due to COVID-19.
    • Administrative Freeze: Boundaries must be established before December 31, 2023.

    This comprehensive array of information serves to prepare stakeholders and functionalities for the ambitious undertaking that is the 2027 Population Census in India, which promises to be innovative in its execution and inclusive in its data gathering.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Centre Challenges States' Writ Petitions

    On Thursday, the Indian government presented its stance before the Supreme Court regarding the ability of states or the Union government to file writ petitions against the actions of the President and Governors concerning bills passed by state assemblies. This matter arose in the context of President Droupadi Murmu seeking clarification from the court on whether states could invoke Article 32 of the Constitution, which pertains to the Right to Constitutional Remedies, for claims of fundamental rights violations.

    Key Points:

    • Article Involvement: The case centers on Article 32, granting rights to seek constitutional remedies, and Article 361, which protects the President and Governors from being legally accountable for their actions.

    • Government's Argument:

      • Solicitor General Tushar Mehta argued that states cannot initiate writ petitions under Article 32 since it is designed to address violations of fundamental rights by the state against individuals. According to Mehta, the scope of Article 32 is limited to actions infringing on individual rights, not those pertaining to state entities.
      • He contended that because the actions of the President are governed by specific constitutional provisions, including Article 131 (pertaining to the Supreme Court's original jurisdiction) and Article 262 (related to inter-state water disputes), the judicial power of the Supreme Court is restricted in these contexts.
    • Constitutional Interpretation: Mehta explained that Part III of the Constitution primarily addresses the individual rights of citizens and does not extend any such rights to states. Therefore, without fundamental rights, states are not positioned to invoke Article 32.

    • Case Reference: The Tamil Nadu government countered the Centre's stance, asserting that the argument claiming a Governor's ability to withhold a Bill reflected a misinterpretation of the Supreme Court decision in Shamsher Singh v State of Punjab (1975).

    • Current Judicial Panel: The issue is being deliberated by a five-judge bench composed of Chief Justice of India B R Gavai along with Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, P S Narasimha, and A S Chandurkar.

    • Context of Inquiry: The Supreme Court's examination is part of a larger discourse on the timeliness of Presidential and gubernatorial actions regarding legislative matters and the potential implications on federal-state dynamics.

    • Judicial Precedent: The matter may hinge on established judicial interpretations, notably past judgments that clarify the extent of jurisdictional overlaps and immunities enjoyed by constitutional officers such as the President and Governors.

    This ongoing case underscores the complexities involved in the relationship between state legislation, executive actions, and judicial oversight in India, particularly as it pertains to the interpretation of constitutional articles designed to serve distinct functions within the governance framework.

    Important Sentences:

    • The Centre claims that states cannot file writ petitions against the President or Governors based on Article 32.
    • Article 32 is centered on violations of individual fundamental rights, not on behalf of state entities.
    • A five-judge bench is currently deliberating on this significant constitutional question.
    • The Tamil Nadu government challenges the Centre's interpretation, referencing a critical Supreme Court ruling from 1975.
    • The discussion reflects broader themes of federalism and the balance of power between state and central authorities within Indian governance.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Delhi Landfills Cleanup by December 2026

    Chief Minister Rekha Gupta of Delhi has set a target for the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) to clear three major landfill sites—Ghazipur, Bhalswa, and Okhla—by December 2026. This directive, issued during a high-level review meeting on solid waste management, aims to address the increasing volume of garbage affecting the city. Previously, Environment Minister Manjinder Singh Sirsa had indicated a goal of eliminating these sites by December 2028.

    The data provided by the MCD reveals that around 153 lakh metric tons (MT) of waste is currently accumulated across these landfill sites, with Ghazipur housing 82 lakh MT (including 19 lakh MT of fresh waste), Bhalswa with 42 lakh MT, and Okhla containing over 28 lakh MT. In response to this crisis, Mayor Raja Iqbal Singh announced that MCD has increased its biomining capacity from 15,000 tonnes per day (TPD) to 25,000 TPD and plans to expedite waste management projects by issuing new tenders for remaining legacy waste. Currently, 56 trommels, which are screening machines utilized for waste separation, are operational at these sites.

    Delhi generates approximately 11,300 MT of waste on a daily basis; however, the city’s four operational waste-to-energy (WTE) plants—situated at Bawana, Tekhand, Okhla, and Ghazipur—only process about 7,300 MT. In a bid to enhance capacity, two new WTE plants are slated for implementation: one with a capacity of 3,000 TPD at Narela-Bawana, expected to commence operations by December 2027, and another with a capacity of 2,000 TPD at Ghazipur, aimed for completion by December 2028. Further expansions of existing facilities at Okhla and Tekhand are projected to add another 1,000 TPD each by 2027, supported by the central government’s commitment of ₹50 crore in viability gap funding for Okhla.

    Despite the timelines presented surpassing Gupta's December 2026 deadline, MCD officials have pledged to intensify efforts to expedite project completions. Delays have been attributed to challenges such as the relocation of power transmission lines, which Gupta has vowed to address with intervention from her office. The Chief Minister emphasized that achieving these targets would necessitate integrated efforts and full cooperation among different government agencies, transcending it being merely an MCD issue.

    Key Points:

    • Chief Minister Rekha Gupta mandates clearing of Ghazipur, Bhalswa, and Okhla landfills by December 2026.
    • Previous target set by Environment Minister was December 2028.
    • Approximately 153 lakh MT of waste is currently at the three landfill sites.
    • Specific waste amounts at landfills: Ghazipur (82 lakh MT), Bhalswa (42 lakh MT), Okhla (28 lakh MT).
    • MCD has increased biomining capacity from 15,000 TPD to 25,000 TPD.
    • Daily waste generation in Delhi is about 11,300 MT; current WTE plants process 7,300 MT.
    • New WTE plants: 3,000 TPD at Narela-Bawana (operational by December 2027), 2,000 TPD at Ghazipur (by December 2028).
    • Plan to expand Okhla and Tekhand plants by 1,000 TPD each by 2027 with government funding.
    • Gupta intends to resolve project delays and stresses need for inter-agency cooperation.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Teaching Nationalism and Equality to Children

    The article explores the author's personal experiences as a Muslim parent in contemporary India, focusing specifically on the implications of communalism faced by his young son. The narrative is set against the backdrop of the attacks on Mumbai on November 26, 2008, drawing a parallel to similar social tensions that persist in society today.

    Key Points:

    • Personal Experience: The author recounts an incident from November 26, 2018, when his six-year-old son was assigned the role of a villain in a game with friends, solely because he is Muslim. This reflects a broader societal issue of communal identity.

    • Impact of Communalism: The child’s inquiry about being called “Pakistani” signifies early exposure to communal prejudice, stimulating questions about the challenges of parenting in an environment marked by religious identification and animosity.

    • Parental Challenges: The author discusses the complexities of modern parenting in a diverse society where children face identity-based discrimination. The tension between preparing children to understand their citizenship rights through the lens of the Constitution and upholding personal beliefs about inclusivity is evident.

    • Cultural Observations: The article mentions how children, influenced by societal norms and media, may adopt discriminatory attitudes, labeling peers based on religion. It emphasizes the challenges in promoting an inclusive understanding of nationalism and citizenship amidst rising religious intolerance.

    • Historical Context: The dialogue surrounding nationalism is framed against the backdrop of a rising "performance nationalism" that emphasizes religious identity and rivalry. This trend is linked to broader socio-political issues in India, affecting how children perceive their peers and themselves.

    • Constitutional Reference: The author advocates for instilling values aligned with the Constitution of India, which guarantees equality and rights for all citizens, regardless of religious affiliation. He highlights the need for parents to ensure their children are aware of their rights.

    • Call for Inclusiveness: The article concludes with an appeal for a more inclusive form of nationalism that embraces India's diversity. The father’s decision to gift his son a copy of the Constitution symbolizes his hope for fostering equitable values.

    Summary of Recommendations and Concerns:

    • Addressing Prejudice: Parents should actively engage in conversations with children to combat religious-based discrimination, advocating for a culture of acceptance.

    • Civic Education: Teaching children about their rights and responsibilities, as enshrined in the Constitution, can equip them to navigate societal prejudices and foster confidence in their identity.

    • Building a Safe Environment: There is a necessity for parents to create spaces where children can express their insecurities and questions about identity without fear of bias.

    • Encouraging Critical Thinking: In the face of sectarian narratives, children should be encouraged to form their own views on nationalism that celebrate diversity rather than division.

    The author presents a poignant reflection on the need for parents, particularly those from marginalized communities, to guide their children through a complex societal landscape while remaining steadfast to the principles of equality and justice as advocated by the Indian Constitution.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    XV FC Grants for Rural Development

    The article discusses the allocation of Rs. 284 crores as the first installment of grants by the Union Government for strengthening Rural Local Bodies (RLBs) in the states of Mizoram, Odisha, and Tripura under the Fifteenth Finance Commission (XV FC) for the financial year 2025-26. This transfer of funds aims to enhance local governance and service delivery in rural areas.

    Key Points:

    • Financial Allocation:

      • The total released amount is Rs. 284 crores.
      • Mizoram has received Rs. 14.2761 crores for 827 eligible Village Councils.
      • Odisha is allocated Rs. 240.8149 crores for 6,085 eligible Gram Panchayats and 63 eligible Block Panchayats.
      • Tripura has been allotted Rs. 29.75 crores for 606 eligible Gram Panchayats, 35 eligible Block Panchayats, 8 eligible Zilla Parishads, all 587 Village Committees, and 40 eligible Block Advisory Committees.
    • Purpose and Utilization:

      • The funds are intended to fulfill location-specific needs of the rural populace as per the Eleventh Schedule of the Constitution, which outlines 29 subjects related to rural governance.
      • The usage of these Untied Grants is restricted for purposes other than salaries and establishment costs.
      • The grants are recommended and released by the Ministry of Panchayati Raj and the Ministry of Jal Shakti.
    • Types of Grants:

      • The article differentiates between Untied Grants and Tied Grants:
        • Untied Grants: Can be used for local needs as specified.
        • Tied Grants: Specifically for the provision of basic services related to sanitation, maintenance of Open Defecation Free (ODF) status, and management of household waste as well as the provision of drinking water and rainy water harvesting.
    • Release Structure:

      • Grants are recommended and released in two installments during a financial year, reflecting a systematic approach to fund allocation and disbursal for local governance.

    This financial support aims to strengthen the efficacy of RLBs and promote sustainable development in rural regions through effective local governance. With these injections of funding, the central government underscores its commitment to enhancing rural infrastructure and community services, thereby improving the quality of life in these regions.

    In conclusion, this initiative is part of a broader strategy targeting rural empowerment and is aligned with the objectives of enhancing democratic processes at the grassroots level, ensuring that government development schemes are responsive and accountable to local needs.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Press Freedom Under Threat in India

    Summary:

    The article revolves around the ongoing challenges to press freedom in India, specifically through the lens of recent events involving journalists Karan Thapar and Siddharth Varadarajan, who have been summoned by the Assam police under allegations of undermining national security. These accusations arise from a First Information Report (FIR) filed on May 9, 2025, alleging their involvement in a conspiracy through their publishing activities at The Wire.

    Highlights:

    • Historical Context: The right to press freedom is constitutionally recognized in India, with a landmark ruling by the Supreme Court in the 1950 Romesh Thappar case affirming its significance.
    • Accusations Against Journalists: Thapar and Varadarajan face accusations tied to producing "offensive" media content that allegedly provokes unrest and endangers national security, as interpreted by the complainant’s claims.
    • Legal Framework: The FIR was scrutinized under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), which has replaced the sedition law that was previously in effect. However, Section 152, which pertains to endangering the sovereignty and integrity of India, is highlighted as potentially having a similar chilling impact on free expression.
    • Supreme Court’s Intervention: The Supreme Court has temporarily prevented coercive actions against the journalists, though concerns remain about the long-term effects on press freedoms and the broader implications for dissent in India.
    • Concerns Regarding Police Practices: The article raises issues with police procedures, emphasizing the financial and logistical burden placed on journalists as the police summon them to Guwahati for questioning, a journey that incurs heavy costs and stress.
    • Calls for Technological Solutions: The article suggests leveraging technology for questioning journalists via video conferencing to mitigate travel burdens and ensure a more efficient investigative process.
    • Potential for Widespread Implications: There is a warning about the potential for the investigation to expand to include other journalists and analysts, impacting a broader spectrum of opinion and dissent.

    Key Points:

    • Press Freedom Under Threat: The situation exemplifies a "murder of press freedom" and has drawn criticism regarding the misuse of laws to silence dissent.
    • Legal and Constitutional Questions: Questions remain about the constitutionality of Section 152 of the BNS and whether it could be viewed as a form of modern sedition.
    • Financial and Emotional Burden: The legal challenges posed by these accusations impose heavy emotional and financial burdens on journalists.
    • Judicial Accountability: Concerns about the Assam police’s disregard for judicial protocols and the required provision of FIR copies highlight significant lapses.
    • Future Implications for Dissent: The invocation of national security as a pretext for silencing criticism poses a serious risk to freedom of expression in India.

    Overall, the article raises critical questions on the interplay between national security, press freedoms, constitutional rights, and the responsibilities of law enforcement, urging for pressing reforms and adherence to judicial mandates in the treatment of media professionals.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Challenges in Indian Constitutional Democracy

    The provided article discusses the challenges faced by the Indian Parliament in upholding constitutional democracy, particularly in relation to lawmaking and judicial oversight. The authors argue that the balance of power between Parliament and the judiciary has been increasingly tilted due to poor legislative practices, leading to significant legislative flaws and increased judicial interventions.

    Key Points of the Article:

    • Constitutional Democracy Challenge: The framers of the Indian Constitution aimed to limit absolute parliamentary sovereignty, maintaining that laws must align with the Constitution, reflecting a desire to prevent Parliament from acting freely without constitutional constraints.

    • Judicial Oversight: The Supreme Court has frequently been required to adjudicate on laws passed by Parliament, which raises concerns regarding parliamentary efficiency. Notably, the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025, faced constitutional challenges soon after its enactment, even from sitting Members of Parliament.

    • Spectrum of Legal Challenges: Legal challenges to legislation can be categorized into constitutional scrutiny, political theatre, and flawed drafting. Factors contributing to these challenges include:

      • Vague definitions and incoherent clauses in laws.
      • Lack of synchronization with existing legislation.
      • Inconsistencies with constitutional provisions.
    • Impact on Governance: Legislative inadequacies adversely affect economic growth, social unity, and the rapport between the legislature and judiciary.

    • Legislative Process: Chapter 9 of the Manual of Parliamentary Procedure outlines a structured process for legislation, including stakeholder consultation and clause-by-clause consideration. However, this process is often compromised:

      • Bills are sometimes rushed through without adequate notice or committee scrutiny.
      • Example: The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, has faced criticism due to its mismatched penalties compared to other laws, indicating potential oversight in legislative drafting.
    • Complexity of Legislation: The convoluted language and rushed consideration of laws hinder effective parliamentary debate. This not only limits the governmental body's engagement but also diminishes the democratic principle of informed participatory governance.

    • Need for Legal Expertise in Parliament: The article advocates for the appointment of a constitutional functionary, potentially the Attorney-General (AG) of India, in parliamentary proceedings. According to Article 88 of the Constitution, the AG can participate in parliamentary discussions, a provision that is underutilized.

    • Benefits of AG's Involvement:

      • The AG could help identify legal inconsistencies during debates, prompting necessary amendments.
      • Lawmakers would benefit from expert non-partisan advice before voting on legislative proposals.
    • Future Implications: A focus on drafting clear and constitutionally sound legislation can help prevent future legal conflicts and reduce the burden on courts, consequently preserving Parliament's legislative intent.

    The article posits that a proactive constitutional review during the legislative process could mitigate the growing trend of judicial manifestations arising from parliamentary incompetence, improving the integrity of the lawmaking process and lawmakers’ capacity to represent diverse social complexities effectively.

    Summary Bullet Points:

    • The framers of the Indian Constitution aimed to prevent absolute parliamentary sovereignty.
    • The Supreme Court frequently adjudicates on parliamentary laws, indicating inefficiencies.
    • Legislative challenges fall under constitutional scrutiny, political theatre, and flawed drafting.
    • Poor legislative practices undermine economic growth and social cohesion.
    • The Manual of Parliamentary Procedure outlines a structured legislative process often poorly executed.
    • Example: The Transgender Persons Act illustrates inconsistencies with penalties in other laws.
    • Complex legal language in bills hinders informed legislative participation.
    • The Attorney-General's participation in parliamentary proceedings could enhance legal soundness.
    • Expert constitutional guidance is essential to prevent flawed legislation and reduce litigation.
    • A proactive review of laws in Parliament could preserve legislative intent and maintain judicial integrity.

    This summary encapsulates the core arguments and observations made in the article, highlighting the need for reform in legislative practices to strengthen Indian democracy.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Navigating Nationalism and Communalism

    The article reflects on the painful experiences faced by a Muslim parent in India, particularly in the context of rising communal sentiments and prejudices that affect children from minority communities. It illuminates personal anecdotes while raising broader societal questions related to nationalism and inclusivity as enshrined in the Indian Constitution.

    Summary:

    • Personal Experience: The author recalls an incident from November 26, 2018, when his six-year-old son was coerced into playing the role of a villain in a game, based solely on his Muslim identity. The child was called a "Pakistani," hinting at early exposure to communal bias, which raises questions about the implications of identity in a diverse society.

    • Parental Challenges: The parent highlights the difficulties in navigating modern parenting amidst rising communal sentiments. There is a struggle to instill values of equality and acceptance in a society where competitive religiosity and performative nationalism are prevalent.

    • Societal Concerns: The article discusses how a generation of children grows up influenced by conversations around nationalism and religion, often leading to hostility toward those identified by different religions. Examples include derogatory comments made toward Muslim friends of the author’s son after a terror attack, highlighting the normalization of bigotry in social interactions.

    • Constitution and Equality: The author reflects on the constitutional guarantees of equality in India, articulated in Article 14, which assures the right to equality before the law and prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth. The tension between such guarantees and real-world prejudice is emphasized as a core concern of modern parenting.

    • Inclusivity and Nationalism: A central theme is the necessity for an inclusive understanding of nationalism that accommodates India's diversity. The author questions whether nationalism can be defined by hatred towards perceived enemies based on religious affiliation and urges a rejection of exclusionary attitudes.

    • Empowerment Through Education: In a bid to empower his son, the author decides to hand him a copy of the Indian Constitution. This gesture symbolizes an attempt to prepare the child for a world rife with challenges and to instill understanding of his rights as a citizen, thereby fostering confidence and self-respect in his identity.

    • Call for Reflection: The piece concludes with an appeal for parents and society to strive harder towards an equitable and inclusive environment. It advocates for nurturing constructive discussions around nationalism, positioning it as a unifying force rather than one that fosters division.

    Key Points:

    • Date Significance: November 26 is marked as a painful reminder of communalism and terror in India.
    • Parental Dilemma: The struggle of Muslim parents to shield their children from communal bias and prepare them for societal challenges.
    • Constitutional Reference: Article 14 of the Indian Constitution emphasizes the right to equality, yet societal prejudices often undermine these principles.
    • Cultural Commentary: The influence of nationalism on children’s perceptions and the expectation to conform to communal narratives is critiqued.
    • Empowerment through Knowledge: Providing children access to the Constitution is seen as a method to cultivate awareness of rights and foster resilience against discrimination.

    This reflective narrative prompts deeper contemplation about the responsibilities of parents and society to combat discrimination and promote inclusivity as a hallmark of Indian identity.

    Polity and Governance

    img

    Third One Health Mission Meeting Held

    Summary: Third Meeting of the Scientific Steering Committee for the National One Health Mission (NOHM)

    The third meeting of the Scientific Steering Committee for the National One Health Mission (NOHM) took place on August 26, 2025, at Vigyan Bhawan Annexe, New Delhi. Led by Prof. Ajay K. Sood, Principal Scientific Adviser to the Government of India, the meeting emphasized the mission's multi-sectoral approach involving multiple ministries and departments, enhancing India's preparedness for health challenges.

    Key Information:

    • Date and Venue: August 26, 2025, at Vigyan Bhawan Annexe, New Delhi.
    • Chairperson: Prof. Ajay K. Sood, Principal Scientific Adviser to the Government of India.
    • Objective: Strengthen national health preparedness via a collaborative One Health framework.

    Attendees:

    • High-ranking officials, including:
      • Dr. Rajiv Bahl (Secretary, DHR, DG ICMR)
      • Dr. M. Ravichandran (Secretary, Ministry of Earth Sciences)
      • Shri Vaidya Rajesh Kotecha (Secretary, Ministry of AYUSH)
      • Dr. Rajesh Gokhale (Secretary, DBT)
      • Dr. V. Narayanan (Chairman, ISRO)
      • Other senior representatives from various health and scientific organizations.

    Important Highlights:

    • Cross-Ministerial Effort: The NOHM now includes the Ministry of Earth Sciences, ISRO, and the Department of Fisheries, bringing the total to 13 participating ministries.
    • Multi-Tiered Governance: Discussions included a suggested three-tier governance model for the implementation of One Health at state, district, and panchayat levels.
    • State Engagements: The first engagement workshop was held on June 9, 2025, focusing on knowledge sharing and coordination among States and Union Territories.
      • Inter-State Linkages: Initiatives for sharing best practices on zoonotic diseases were established between states such as Assam-Uttar Pradesh and Goa-Karnataka.
    • Youth Engagement: Plans for youth involvement through hackathons and ideathons aimed at addressing One Health issues were discussed.

    Reports and Recommendations:

    • Updates were shared regarding the Advisory and Review Committees focusing on:
      • Bio-safety Level Laboratory Network
      • Technology-enhanced outbreak investigation
      • Research and development of medical countermeasures
      • Integration of data for national surveillance.

    Action Points:

    • Recommendations were laid out for:
      • Development of a National Outbreak Data Repository.
      • Strengthening wastewater surveillance and overall surveillance systems.
      • Enhancing laboratory capabilities through network inclusion and capacity building.
      • Rolling out a unified e-learning module tailored for officials of states and UTs.

    Conclusion:

    Prof. Sood emphasized that the collaborative nature of NOHM allows for a comprehensive approach towards health challenges. The significant progress made can further benefit from the adoption of the above recommendations aiming to build a nationally scoped and globally significant One Health framework.

    Bullet Points:

    • NoHM's Third Meeting: Held on August 26, 2025, led by Prof. Ajay K. Sood.
    • Objective: Strengthening India's health preparedness through inter-ministerial collaboration.
    • New Ministries Involved: Ministry of Earth Sciences, ISRO, Department of Fisheries.
    • Governance Model: Proposal for a three-tier governance framework.
    • Engagement Workshops: First workshop on June 9, 2025, to enhance cooperation among states.
    • Youth Involvement: Aimed for solutions through hackathons/ideathons.
    • Key Updates from Advisory Committees: Presented on various operational aspects of One Health.
    • Future Plans: Including national data repositories, wastewater surveillance, and enhanced laboratory capacity.

    Polity and Governance

    WhatsApp